The speed selection of Roots blower needs to be balanced according to specific operating conditions, and the key is to match the application scenario. Here is a professional analysis:
---
**1、 Advantages and disadvantages of high speed (>1500rpm)**
**Advantages**
1. * * Increase in air volume * *:
-The air volume is proportional to the rotational speed, making it suitable for scenarios that require high air volume, such as aerating tanks.
2. * * Compact equipment * *:
-Under the same air volume, high-speed fans have a smaller volume and save space.
3. * * Low cost * *:
-The procurement cost of small high-speed fans is usually lower than that of low-speed large models.
**Disadvantages**
1. * * Wear Acceleration * *:
-The service life of bearings and gears is shortened (when the speed is doubled, the theoretical service life is reduced to 1/8).
2. * * Increased noise * *:
-High frequency noise is significant (>85dB, muffler needs to be installed).
3. * * Frequent maintenance * *:
-The replacement cycle of lubricating oil is shortened (such as 300 hours vs 1000 hours for low-speed machines).
**Typical applications: small-scale sewage treatment, pneumatic conveying (power<30kW).
---
**2、 Advantages and disadvantages of low speed (<1000rpm)**
**Advantages**
1. * * Stable operation * *:
-Low mechanical stress and low failure rate (suitable for 24/7 continuous operation).
2. * * Longer lifespan * *:
-Bearings and gears wear slowly, and the overhaul cycle can reach more than 5 years.
3. * * Energy Efficiency Optimization * *:
-Under high-pressure conditions (>58.8kPa), the efficiency is higher.
**Disadvantages**
1. * * High initial cost * *:
-The same air volume requires a larger impeller, which increases equipment cost by 30-50.
2. * * Large volume * *:
-Need for larger installation space (such as large fans used in cement plants).
**Typical applications: Chemical high-pressure transportation, metallurgical industry (power>75kW).
---
**3、 Core principles of selection**
**Prioritize selecting high-speed scenarios**
-Short term intermittent operation (such as less than 8 hours per day).
-Space is limited and there is a high demand for air volume.
-Small and medium-sized projects with limited budgets.
**Prioritize selecting low-speed scenarios**
-24-hour continuous operation.
-High pressure, high temperature or corrosive medium working conditions.
-Sensitive to noise (such as urban sewage treatment plants).
---
**4、 Technical Comparison Table**
|* * Comparison item * * | * * High speed fan * * | * * Low speed fan * *|
|------------------|---------------------|---------------------|
|Wind volume adjustment range | Wide (easy to adjust with frequency conversion) | Narrow (requires mechanical speed regulation)|
|Maintenance cost | High (2-3 maintenance per year) | Low (1 maintenance per year)|
|Applicable pressure | ＜ 49kPa | ＞ 49kPa|
|Typical efficiency | 65~75 | 75~85|
---
**5、 Misconception warning**
1. Abuse of frequency converter:
-Long term low-frequency operation of high-speed fans can lead to poor lubrication (insufficient oil pump flow).
2. Overpressure risk:
-Increasing the speed will not increase the pressure, but it may cause the motor to overload (power ∝ speed 3).
3. * * Brand Differences * *:
-The lifespan of Japanese/branded high-speed fans may be better than that of domestic low-speed models (due to differences in material and process).
---
**6、 Professional advice**
1. * * Economic Choice * *:
-Calculate the total cost for 10 years (procurement+energy consumption+maintenance), and low-speed machines are more cost-effective in the long run.
2. * * Customized solution * *:
-High voltage operating conditions can be selected with "low-speed machine+frequency converter", balancing efficiency and adjustment flexibility.
3. * * Actual testing verification * *:
-Entrust the manufacturer to provide vibration/temperature test reports for similar operating conditions.
**Conclusion: When selecting, priority should be given to meeting process requirements, followed by comprehensive consideration of cost and lifespan. For large-scale projects, it is recommended to consult with wind turbine manufacturers for CFD fluid simulation optimization.
